What are Air Bearings? Basically, air bearings use a thin film of
pressurized air to support a load, the same way the puck on an air
hockey table "floats" on air. This type of bearing is
called a "fluid film" bearing. Fluid film bearings have
no solid-to-solid contact under typical running conditions; instead,
a film of lubricating fluid (in our case pressurized air) forms
a layer between the solid machine elements and serves to transfer
forces from one to the other. To compare this with ball bearings,
in ball bearings the balls are in constant contact with and form
a solid bridge between the machine elements.
Approximate Pressure Profile
in an Air Bearing
The fluid is able to transfer forces because
as the fluid is pushed through the bearing gap it generates
a pressure profile across the bearing area. The force the
bearing can support is then:
Force = Avg. Pressure x Area
The actual pressure distribution in the bearing
varies based on the bearing design and other parameters but
a good rule of thumb is to expect 30% efficiency.
Force = 0.3 x Supply Pressure
x Area
For flat
pads and rectangular bearings this calculation is quite straightforward,
but for journal and spherical bearings we use a few other
approximations to estimate load capacity.
Fluid film bearings offer a
number of advantages over mechanical bearings. First, because there
is no contact, air bearings do not suffer from wear or heat generation
due to friction. They also exhibit no starting or running friction,
even under their highest design loading. In addition, the fluid
film acts to center and average out small scale errors in the components
resulting in motion which can be more accurate than the individual
bearing components. Air bearings also offer much higher stiffness
than rolling element bearings because the air film fully supports
the components, as opposed to balls or rollers which have point
or line contact and are therefore limited due to Hertzian contact
stiffness.
Air Bearing
Benefits:
No solid to solid contact - no wear, particles, lubricants
Zero Static Friction
Zero Running Friction
High Stiffness
Self centering
Error Averaging
Why use Air? While most people are familiar with
oil fluid film bearings - for example the crankshaft journal bearings
in car engines - most people have not been exposed to air bearings.
Remembering our high school physics class, there are two basic types
of fluids - liquids and gasses. In terms of fluid film bearings,
the difference between these two is essentially the viscosity -
liquids have much higher viscosity than gasses. When applied to
a fluid film bearing, this difference has a number of implications.
First, lower viscosity means that for the
same working pressure gas bearings have lower load capacity (liquid
fluid film bearings typically support five times the load of gas
bearings for the same pad area). Second, because of the extremely
low viscosity of gasses, gas film bearings operate with essentially
zero static and running friction where liquid fluid film bearings
have much higher friction and pumping losses within the bearings,
which can cause heat generation. And third, gas bearings require
very tight bearing gaps for proper operation (10 µm for gas
compared to up to 100 µm for liquid bearing) which translates
into extremely high accuracy requirements on the components.
What this means for air bearings is that although they have a lower
load capacity, gas bearings have essentially zero friction at all
speeds and because the tight bearing clearances demand high accuracy
components this results in extremely high accuracy motion. Another
benefit is the cleanliness of using air as a lubricating fluid as
opposed to oil, water, or another fluid. Since compressed air is
very common in industrial environments it is probably the most often
used gas, however other gasses such as nitrogen
can be used where they are available (such as in clean room environments).
Why we use air (instead of oil):
Air is clean, contaminant free
Zero friction - no heat generation at high
speeds
Small bearing gap means high accuracy components,
high accuracy motion
Air, nitrogen or any other gas can be used
Hydrostatic vs. Hydrodynamic?
The first question is how to generate the pressurized supply of
fluid for the bearing. There are two ways to do this - one is using
an external pressurized supply (hydrostatic) and the other is to
use the relative motion of the machine components to generate the
pressure internally (hydrodynamic or "self-generating").
While hydrodynamic bearings are common for oil fluid film bearings,
which generate internal pressures quite easily due to the relatively
high viscosity of oil, it is much rarer to see this technique used
for air bearings because the pressure generated is quite low (although
Nelson Air has built bearings of this type for low load, high speed
rotary applications such as optical scanners).
Hydrodynamic:
Relative motion generates
Pressure
Hydrostatic:
External Pressure Supply
Our typical air bearings are hydrostatic (or in our case aerostatic)
and use a compressed air supply to create the fluid film. This supply
should be clean and regulated to a constant pressure - simple off
the shelf air handling components are more than adequate for most
applications to clean, dehumidify, and regulate the supply. Typical
operating pressures run as low as 20 psi up to 120 psi depending
on the stiffness, load capacity, and air consumption requirements.
Porous Carbon Flat Pad
Porous Bronze Bushing
Drilled Nozzles with
Pocketed Compensation ("Setbacks")
Jewel Nozzle with
Pocketed Compensation
How does the air get into the
bearing?
After entering the bearing and being routed though internal passages,
the next step is to feed the pressurized air to where it is needed
- namely directly into the bearing gap. There are two basic ways
to accomplish this, orifices and porous media. For orifices, the
air flows through a small hole (typically .004" to .015"
dia.) into the bearing area. Porous media bearings use a porous
material (typically carbon, bronze, or steel) which the air penetrates
through into the bearing area.
The relative benefits of each approach are debatable. While orifices
typically do not generate as uniform a pressure profile as can be
achieved with porous media, there are ways to improve the pressure
profile using a technique called "pocketed compensation".
Porous media feeding provides more inherent damping than orifices,
however proper sizing of the orifices can adjust damping. Orifices
can become plugged if a very large particle gets into the air supply
(this is extremely rare), where the porous media acts as a filter
for the air. However, because of this filtering effect, over time
the porous media itself can become clogged (oil vapor in the air
is particularly bad) and a clogged porous bearing is much more difficult
to clear than a clogged orifice.
Orifice fed bearings can be made from one piece of material (particularly
when using drilled nozzles) where porous bearings are necessarily
made using varying materials and adhesives.
At Nelson Air we have used both orifice and porous media feeding.
Most of our standard products use pocket compensated orifices, however
our LB series of linear bushings use porous bronze. Our typical
orifice bearings are made using a special technique we have developed
to drill the small orifices directly into the bearing, instead of
using pressed in or glued in jewel nozzles. We believe that this
technique reduces cost and complexity while increasing long term
stability and reliability. However, jeweled nozzles are used when
the design precludes drilled nozzles either because of geometry
or because especially small orifice sizes (.004" for example)
are required.
Air Film Averages out
Local Variations
Accuracy
Precision
Repeatability
Typical Air Bearing Specs:
Linear Accuracy:
10 µin/in, 100 µin/36 in
Rotary Accuracy:
±1 µin TIR
Roll/Pitch/Yaw:
0.25 arcsec/in
Linear Repeatability:
±10 µin
Rotary Repeatability:
1 µin
Positioning Resolution:
to ±1 encoder count
Geometry, Geometry, Geometry!
Because of the very small gaps that are required for air bearings,
the single most important factor in their manufacture is absolutely
flawless geometry. Any variation in part size, straightness, squareness
or out of roundness will result in a closing of the gap and will
cause the bearing to lose its frictionless nature as well as degrade
accuracy and load capacity. Typical tolerances on our rectangular
bearings which run air gaps of ~0.00075" are part deviations
less than ±0.0001" overall. This same tolerance applies
over the entire length of the bearing, which for some models can
be over 60".
In addition, the part geometry is what determines the accuracy
of the final bearing motion - even though local deviations are averaged
out by the air film, the overall accuracy is dictated by how well
the parts are made. Because of this, Nelson Air has developed a
variety of techniques and equipment which allow us to meet these
stringent tolerances with repeatability and relatively low cost.
On Accuracy, Precision and Repeatability
To start this discussion it is best to briefly define what accuracy,
precision and repeatability mean.
Accuracy is the measure of how closely the motion follows an
ideal profile.
Precision is the measure of how small the motion increments
can be.
Repeatability is the measure of how well the motion moves along
the same path.
Air bearings offer the best of all worlds because they have excellent
accuracy, precision and repeatability. They offer high accuracy
because the components are manufactured with extremely tight tolerances
and because of the air film's averaging effects. Typical linear
accuracies are 10 µin/in with maximum deviation of 100 µin/36
in. Rotary runout can be as low ±1 µin. Air bearings
also offer extremely good tilt characteristics - 0.25 arcsec/in.
Because air bearings exhibit no stiction or running friction, the
precision achievable is only limited by the abilities of the motor/controller/encoder.
Positioning precision of ±1 encoder count can easily be achieved
using linear motors.
The repeatability of air bearings far exceeds that of mechanical
bearings for the simple reason that they have no contact or wear.
Heat generation in mechanical bearings sometimes require "warm
up" periods during which there is thermal movement. Also, the
mechanical preload on roller bearings can vary with temperature
and cause the bearings to operate differently (varying friction
for example) and lack repeatability. When working at the highest
accuracy levels, these effects can cause mechanical bearings to
lose their accuracy from hour to hour, day to day, or month to month.
Because the accuracy of our air bearings is built into its solid
metal components (made from one type of material for uniform thermal
expansion), they can operate for years without any degradation in
accuracy. This way, a calibration done one day will "stick".
They also can be run at top speed without any need for warm-up time
(excluding motor heating effects) and maintain their best accuracy.
Method 1: Weight used to preload bearing
Method 2: Vacuum Preload
Method 3: Magnetic Preload
Method 4: Opposing Air Bearing Preload
Preloading Air Bearings
While some configurations of air bearings are self-preloading (e.g.
journal bearings) others such as flat pads and linear rectangular
bearings can benefit from preload. Air bearings can be used without
any preload (such as a simple flat pad riding on a granite surface),
however, in order to maximize the stiffness of the air bearing and
help maintain constant air gap it is typical to preload it using
one of four basic methods:
Weight Preload
Vacuum Preload
Magnetic Preload
Opposing Air Bearing Preload
The simplest method is weight. Using a weight much heavier than
the expected variation in the loading of the bearing preloads the
air bearing so it rides at a smaller (and stiffer) air gap and makes
it less prone to height variations. This method has the drawback
of adding moving mass but can work very will with systems which
already have a large amount of mass and low forces (such as parts
inspection). Needless to say, this only works for bearings which
operate horizontally.
The second method is using a vacuum preload. A vacuum is used to
apply a preloading force to the air bearing (instead of using a
weight). This is accomplished by providing an area of the bearing
surface over which a vacuum is applied. Because vacuum is limited
to around negative 14 psi (atmospheric pressure) and typical air
bearing pressures are 40-80 psi the net effect is still a lifting
of the bearing, even when the bearing and vacuum areas are equal.
Vacuum preload enhances the stiffness and helps to maintain constant
air gap, without adding unnecessary moving mass. The main drawbacks
to this method are the need for a larger bearing area to accommodate
both pressure and vacuum and the requirement of a vacuum source.
This method has been used successfully in many applications, especially
for flat pads and planar systems which do not lend themselves to
other forms of preload.
The third method of preloading is magnetic preload. Magnetic attraction
between a magnet on the moving part and a magnetic material on the
stationary part of the bearing loads the bearing and adds stiffness.
This configuration works well for linear bearings and can be very
cost effective because it reduces the tolerances required for the
air bearing components (as compared to air bearing preloaded systems).
However, because many air bearings are made from nonmagnetic materials,
it requires adding other materials to the bearing (such as iron).
Another drawback is that at high speeds, the magnet generates eddy
currents in the iron which oppose the motion and add a drag force
(eliminating the "zero friction" of air bearings). However,
in many applications magnetic preload provides an effective method
of preloading air bearings.
The final method is opposing air bearing preload. This method uses
opposing air bearings to preload each other. This method provides
twice the stiffness of a single air bearing, although the load capacity
is reduced by almost half (the other preload methods also reduce
load capacity, based on the amount of force they apply) and is very
effective in producing the most accurate and reliable air bearings.
Because there are two air bearings working in parallel it also has
the effect of averaging any errors on either bearing (centering)
and can therefore deliver higher accuracy than any other method.
In addition, air bearing preloaded bearings can be operated in any
orientation. The majority of Nelson Air's standard bearings use
this method because we believe it provides the highest quality,
accuracy and versatility. However, this method does require higher
accuracy components with more precision surfaces.
Various Configurations
for Air Bearings:
Now that you understand the basics of how air bearings work, here
are some of the most common configurations for using them to create
motion with a variety of degrees of freedom. If you have any additional
questions, please contact us and we
would enjoy assisting you.
Flat Pad:
Planar (XY) and Rotary Motion
Air Bushing/ Journal Bearing:
Linear and Rotary Motion
Rectangular Air Bearing:
Linear Motion Only
Dovetail Air Bearing:
Linear Motion Only
Spindle:
Rotary Motion Only, High Radial Loads
Rotary Table:
Rotary Motion Only, High Axial Loads
Spherical Air Bearing:
3 Rotational Degrees of Freedom